The Bucks’ second invitation in three seasons to the College Football Playoff went everything but as planned. They matched up against the ACC champion Clemson Tigers in the Fiesta Bowl which takes place in Glendale, Arizona. The Tigers wasted no time turning the Buckeyes’ dream of returning a national title to Columbus into a nightmare when they ran up the score to a tune of 31-0 on New Year’s Eve. The final score and outcome of this game was certainly a surprise to Buckeye fans everywhere as well as to many college football spectators across the country. This includes myself. However, looking back on this game it really shouldn’t be incredibly surprising that the Bucks got beat in the way that they did. Of course hindsight is 20/20 but this match up was bound to be problematic from start to finish. Getting badly embarrassed in the last game was not at all what the Buckeyes and their fans had in mind but now looking back it seemed to be inevitable.
It’s been no secret that the Buckeyes like to run the ball. They were 18th in the country in rushing attempts per game. Their 245 rushing yards per game (five and a half yards per carry) was good for twelfth overall which made them by far the best in the Big Ten and put them right behind Alabama in ranks. The Bucks’ leading rusher this season was red-shirt freshman Mike Weber whose 1096 rushing yards was good for sixth in the Big Ten. His six yards per carry mark was good for third in the Big Ten (100 carry minimum). The downside to this was that it was the only thing they could do well. Though being a run-first team has been in the program’s genes for quite some time, they haven’t looked much more one dimensional than they have now. The superior Buckeye running game was backed by an inferior passing game. As far as passing offense goes, their 214 yards through the air per game puts them at 82nd in the country. Junior quarterback J.T. Barrett was the sole owner of the offense in the 2016 season after spending 2015 in limbo for the starting spot with Cardale Jones in the mix. His 2555 passing yards this season put him at 58th in the country and his 24 touchdown passes had him at 30th. Barrett has always been a solid dual-threat quarterback for the Bucks since he first began as the starter in 2014. In fact, he received attention in the Heisman race in 2014 for his unexpectedly great regular season performance in place of injured Braxton Miller. Since then, Barrett’s play has wavered a bit. Whether it’s been a lack of confidence after having to battle for his job back when he got injured during the 2014 season, throwing to new receivers, recent offensive line issues, or dealing with changes in offensive coordinator is anyone’s guess. With that in mind, what was most worrisome had to have been the fact that the leading receiver for the Bucks was none other than star running back Curtis Samuel. Normally you’d want to see one of your receivers up their on the list of receiving statistics for the team. In the Bucks’ case, Curtis Samuel is by far the leading receiver of this team with 74 receptions, 865 yards, and seven touchdowns. The next receiver down the list is Noah Brown with 32 receptions, 402 yards, and seven touchdowns. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure out what this Ohio State offense was about. When a player listed as a running back is doubling up the top wide receiver in receptions/receiving yards then you know there’s something going on. Samuel was also the Buckeyes’ most productive rusher with 771 yards on the ground (7.9 yards per carry) and eight touchdowns. Having that one player who does it all is great but it doesn’t lack its negatives. The Curtis Samuel factor of Ohio State’s offense made it great but also left it vulnerable. The moral of the story is that the Bucks were able to survive the Big Ten without using much variety in their offense by relying on Curtis Samuel’s elite talent and Weber/Barrett running the ball. Getting by on that strategy could only hold up for so long until they met up with a team that could effectively game plan against it…
Image Credit: Art Foxall/UPI
This abysmal performance on offense against Clemson has many people wondering about what happened to the 2016 Buckeye offensive domination that occurred against Oklahoma (45-24), Nebraska (62-3), and Maryland (62-3). The answer that makes the most sense is that the defenses of those teams are not very good especially considering Oklahoma and Maryland rank outside the top 75 in total defense. In this match up, the Bucks were going up against Clemson who is the eighth ranked total defense in the country. Now before we delve into how Clemson used their defense to shut down Ohio State’s attack, I want to remark on the how this defense relates to a similar match up Ohio State faced this season. When the Bucks played Michigan in what turned out to be the de facto Big Ten championship game, they were tops in the nation in total defense and passing yards allowed. This makes them much better than the Tigers. So why did the Bucks hang 30 points on Michigan and get shut out by Clemson? Michigan allowed Barrett to get outside the pocket and pick up yards using his legs. Yes, they held Samuel to under 100 total yards from scrimmage, Weber to just 23 yards, and Barrett to just about nothing through the air but they seemingly forgot that Barrett can run the ball too. He ran for 125 yards and a touchdown on 30 carries. And all of this is without even mentioning the fact that their quarterback Wilton Speight turned the ball over three times in the worst places possible including a pick six he threw to allow the Bucks to get their first points on the board, a fumble on the Bucks’ one yard line, and throwing a pick on his own 30 yard line. All of this must have looked very familiar for the Buckeyes when Clemson made mistakes and Deshaun Watson threw them two picks. The first of those two occurred on Watson’s first drive of the game which was right after the Bucks came out looking completely out of sorts on their first drive. That interception by Gareon Conley on Clemson’s own 33 yard line was a huge momentum changer that should have easily turned into points and an early lead. Instead, the Bucks came out and squandered what turned out to be one of many opportunities that Clemson gave the Bucks to make this a game. A quick three and out was the product of that turnover which led to a missed field goal. The next opportunity missed was when Parris Campbell returned the kickoff following their made field goal for 54 yards to Clemson’s 42 yard line. This was another chance to make some noise and completely reestablish momentum. The offense did move the ball all the way to their 22 yard line but eventually lost enough yards to make it a 47 yard field goal which was missed. Then, there was the fluke 31 yard field goal miss by Clemson which gave them an empty possession and the Bucks the ball. They followed that missed field goal with two three and outs. Clemson also shut down every facet of the Ohio State run game. They limited them to 88 total rushing yards. The outcome against Michigan was much different than that of the outcome against Clemson in just a couple ways but namely because of the missed opportunities that the Bucks did cash in on against their rival.
Since I brought up the missed field goals, I would like to state that I put more blame on the offense for the misses than anything. Yes, as a senior kicker for Ohio State, he should be able to make field goals like that (nothing worse than a good football team who for some reason has an unreliable kicker) but the offense should have been much more efficient on those possessions. On both of the possessions that resulted in missed field goals, the Bucks started well inside Clemson territory (Conley interception and Parris Campbell 54 yard kick return). The offense didn’t move the ball more than about ten yards on each possession which in turn wasted prime opportunities to score given their starting field position. I’m also confused as to why people are giving this much extreme criticism to the kicker. This kid was kicking in what was the biggest game of his life after just having a poor performance in the last game he played in against Michigan. He was actually having a pretty good regular season up until the Michigan game. His confidence was shot and the offense really didn’t help him very much by setting him up for two 47 yard field goals. That’s the second thing I want to remark on. A 47 yard field goal is most definitely not a walk in the park. There are many times in NFL games every Sunday where kickers miss 33 yard point after attempts much less 47 yard field goals. The thing about this that is most confusing is that people are still giving him grief about his missed field goals even though they had nothing to do with the outcome of the game. Ohio State would have had a nice six points come out of those possessions and maybe a little momentum but the Bucks were simply outmatched regardless. I mean 31-0 isn’t typically considered a close game. It would have been much different if the Bucks were to have lost against Michigan due to field goal misses because that game was marginally closer. I would have definitely condoned some criticism of the kicker’s 21 yard field miss in that case.
One thing that I really do not understand and can’t get over about this game is the play calling. The Buckeyes’ first hand off to a running back wasn’t until their third possession of the game where they handed it off to Samuel who ran sideways for a loss of eight yards. I understand that the Bucks likely came into this game knowing that Clemson was going to go all out on stopping the run (which they did) but running the ball is what they do best and that’s what got them there so they should have at least made a concerted effort on getting it going before they got too far behind. Clemson’s interior defense may be strong but the Bucks needed to keep them honest. It would have been especially smart to get Weber going early and often in this game because as a first year player in a game like this he needed to get his feet wet and confidence up. Weber’s fumbling issues in this game looked like it may have come from him trying to do too much. Curtis Samuel and Mike Weber combined for just 11 carries in this game. Weber should have had half of that in the first two possessions. Barrett ran the ball as much as Samuel and Weber combined with his 11 carries which totaled to -2 yards at the end of the night. Ohio State only managed 88 yards on the ground on 23 attempts. The run game is essential to any game plan especially in a tough match up such as this. Apparently it wasn’t in Ohio State’s.
Image Credit: Aaron Doster – USA TODAY Sports
There really isn’t much to say about the passing game for the Bucks in this match up so here’s some numbers that should tell the story. The passing game was technically the most productive aspect of the offense with Barrett completing 19/33 pass attempts (58%) for 127 yards. However, he did throw two interceptions. The first interception was a high pass to Curtis Samuel where the ball deflected off his hands and into the hands of a Clemson defender. That was a good pass but it sailed just a tad too high for the smaller Samuel to haul in. The other pick was just a prayer that Barrett threw up in desperation on a long fourth toward the end zone where Clemson defenders ran in and just picked it off. They took that one all the way back to the Bucks’ 20 yard line where they scored another touchdown to make it 31-0. I do respect Barrett’s decision to be aggressive on those times he threw picks and take shots down field to try and make big plays happen for his team in their deficit. However, he only seemed to start taking shots down the field when it was obvious that it was coming. It seemed like only in desperation did the Bucks go down the field. Clemson does have a pretty good secondary with Cordrea Tankersley and Jadar Johnson but the way that Clemson was loading the box early seemed to at least open up something down the field. If any early passing was going to catch Clemson off guard in this game, it would for sure have been some deep passes. A perfect example of this was right before the first interception happened where Barrett drew two defensive pass interference calls on Clemson when he dialed up consecutive deep balls. Though they were a bit under thrown, he put major pressure on the defense and led the Bucks to what could have been their most productive drive. Unfortunately, it was already too late for the Bucks so there wasn’t much left they could do regardless.
The battle between Ohio State’s offensive line and Clemson’s defensive line was easily the marquee match up in this game. Except this battle was more of a pummeling. It’s safe to say Clemson’s defensive line made Ohio State’s line look like they didn’t even belong on the same field. Ohio State’s offensive line gave no resistance at all even when Clemson would only rush four. This allowed their defense to sit back in coverage and not allow any lanes for Barrett to throw into while also bringing pressure. Some of this can be attributed to starting left guard Michael Jordan getting injured on the first drive (returned and played injured). You could also attribute it to right tackle Isaiah Prince doing his best impression of a piece of Swiss cheese during the game. The Clemson defense accounted for 11 total tackles for loss and three sacks. These numbers would have been much higher if Barrett wasn’t such a mobile quarterback and unable to escape the frequent line collapses.
Image Credit: factoryofsadness.co
To end this on a good note, the Buckeye defense played fairly well in this game considering what they had to work with. The Clemson offense did put up 31 points on them but it really could have been so much worse. The Bucks’ offensive blunders were so bad that it made the defense stay on the field for the vast majority of the game. The Bucks were 3-14 on 3rd down. The time of possession in this game favored Clemson 35:51 to Ohio State’s 24:09. With Clemson averaging about 40 points per game, it’s hard to be on defense for that long and hold an offense like Clemson’s down. The defense kept Ohio State in the game for the most part by keeping the score at 17-0 until late in the third quarter. All the offense needed to do was score and it would have been a game. With the offense not putting any pressure on Clemson, the Buckeye defense finally did give out. Raekwon McMillan gave it all he had in what would be his last game as a Buckeye in this contest. He was in on what seemed like just about every play. His 15 total tackles, 12 solo tackles, two tackles for loss, and one sack led the team. Gareon Conley and Malik Hooker each had an interception to end their times as Buckeyes. Linebacker Chris Worley added 10 total tackles with eight solo tackles.
Featured Image Credit: (AP / Ross D. Franklin) – http://www.newsday.com
If you liked this article and would like to read more similar this one, please visit Alec’s Ohio Sports Blog at alecdhartman.wordpress.com. If you would like to be notified when new articles are posted, go to alecdhartman.wordpress.com and click the follow button in the lower right hand corner.